Pipeline work threatens Virginians

July 3, 2020 12:36 am

Workers had begun laying portions of the Mountain Valley Pipeline in Roanoke County near the Blue Ridge Parkway in 2018. (Ned Oliver/Virginia Mercury – July 26, 2018)

By Emily Little

As health care professionals concerned about the health of our patients, our communities, and our planet, let us be clear: building out fossil fuel infrastructure that is neither safe nor needed is a bad idea.  Building it in the midst of a pandemic that is disproportionately harming racial and ethnic minority communities is an even worse idea.

The Mountain Valley Pipeline (MVP) is a $5.5 billion bad idea. It is not needed. Only a fraction the fracked gas it would carry from West Virginia is slated for Virginia. And the project has shown consistent disregard for the welfare of Virginians. The company has paid over $2 million in fines for ignoring Virginia law. In October, the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals vacated the project’s Nationwide 12 permit, and last year,  the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC)  issued a stop work order, based on threats to endangered species. As a result, work on the pipeline has largely ceased, with the exception of erosion and sediment control maintenance performed by a small workforce.

Yet, as if these were not reason enough to abandon this folly, COVID-19 has delivered another.

The CEO of MVP’s parent company assured investors on a May 14 earnings call that “as soon as” the federal stop-work order is lifted, probably in July, “we will fully mobilize and get upwards of 4,000 people right [a]way”.  Bringing 4,000 out-of-state workers into our vulnerable communities poses significant health risks to Virginians. While Virginia is successfully reducing our rates of infection, these workers would come from multiple states across the country. They procure housing in clusters at hotels and campgrounds, huddle for morning instructions, congregate after hours, and commute to job sites by the school busload. Close contact among workers puts them at risk and makes them potential vehicles for transmission of COVID-19 to the community.

The danger posed by thousands of workers building a multi-billion dollar construction project in the commonwealth is not hypothetical.  In April, about 20 workers at a small construction site at Cave Spring High School near Roanoke, many from out of state, tested positive for COVID-19. There is good reason to expect that this experience would be repeated, given that MVP has ignored social distancing requirements during the maintenance work allowed under FERC’s stop work order. Monitors from a community group, Mountain Valley Watch, took photographs that show MVP workers congregating in groups closer than six feet and without facemasks, despite state protocols.

The risks in Virginia are heightened by where, according to the MVP earnings call, the “vast majority of the remaining work” would take place. Most of the remaining work is “30 miles of upland work.”  This presumptively includes areas such as Giles and Craig counties, where, according to MVP’s own weekly compliance reports, the project is less than 20 percent complete, and in Montgomery and Roanoke counties, where it is less than 50 percent complete.

These counties have limited access to health care and an extreme shortage of Intensive Care Unit beds. With approximately 100 ICU beds in the entire six county area, the health system along the MVP route clearly is not well equipped to deal with an outbreak of COVID-19 brought by out-of-state workers. Furthermore, the population is extremely vulnerable to COVID-19 due to higher concentrations of people 65 and older, of people in poverty, and of people with COPD and cardiovascular disease than in Virginia as a whole.

The health of Virginians should not be held hostage to an out-of-state company’s boondoggle that provides almost no benefit to Virginia’s energy supply. Virginia Clinicians for Climate Action has consistently held the position that both the MVP and the Atlantic Coast Pipeline pose risks to our health and our future. Continued work on these dangerous projects during a pandemic only heightens the threat they pose to Virginians. We ask our state health officials and Gov. Ralph Northam to halt all construction on the Mountain Valley Pipeline.

Emily Little is a mother and nurse working to center our priorities around the health of people and our common home.  She is a member of Virginia Clinicians for Climate Action. She lives in Charlottesville.

Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.

Guest Column
Guest Column

Views of guest columnists are their own. To submit an op-ed for consideration, contact Commentary Editor Samantha Willis at [email protected].