The Virginia State Corporation Commission on Friday approved Dominion Energy Virginia’s proposed Coastal Virginia Offshore Wind project, but not happily.
A news release from the SCC complains about the “excessive costs” of the two turbines about 27 miles off the coast of Virginia Beach and the way it is structured to make customers, rather than the developer, shoulder risks:
“The commission determined that the company’s proposal puts ‘essentially all’ of the risk of the project, including cost overruns, production and performance failures, on Dominion’s customers. Currently, the estimated cost of the project is at least $300 million, excluding financing costs,” the SCC said.
Purchasing wind power from third-party developers, the commission found, “would likely have put all or some of the risks on developers as has been done with other offshore wind projects along the East Coast.”
Any economic benefits, it added, “are speculative, whereas the risks and excessive costs are definite and will be borne by Dominion’s customers.”
In spite of these harsh words, the SCC goes on to conclude that the language of the giant energy bill passed by the General Assembly last winter, SB 966, leaves regulators no choice but to approve CVOW:
“Recent amendments to Virginia laws that mandate that such a project be found to be ‘in the public interest’ make it clear that certain factual findings must be subordinated to the clear legislative intent expressed in the laws governing the petition,” the commission said.
Obviously, the SCC has a point about the high cost of CVOW. Even Dominion agreed that if you just want 12 megawatts of power, you can get it a lot more cheaply than $300 million. The SCC’s final order is even harsher on this topic. Moreover, the SCC doesn’t see any future for offshore wind as a matter of pure economics.
Nor is it all that reassuring that Dominion has said the price tag won’t have any impact on rates. What Dominion means is that we ratepayers have already paid for it, and as we aren’t going to get our money back anyway, we may as well enjoy seeing it put to use in building an offshore wind industry.
That’s where Dominion is (sort of) right, and the SCC (sort of) wrong. CVOW is the first step in the Northam administration’s plan to build an offshore wind industry in Virginia and install at least 2,000 MW of offshore wind turbines in the coming decade, a goal shared by many members of the General Assembly.
Northam says CVOW will lead to the commercial projects. Dominion says maybe, maybe not (“It’s too soon to have that conversation,” in the words of Dominion’s Katharine Bond). At any rate, it sure won’t happen without CVOW first.
Critics have said it’s silly to insist on a pilot project when other states are going forward with full-scale wind farms. That’s not entirely fair.
As the first project in federal waters, the first in the mid-Atlantic and the first to be located 27 miles out to sea, CVOW’s two turbines will have much to teach the industry about offshore wind installation and performance in this part of the world. The whole U.S. offshore wind industry stands to benefit.
And also, Dominion has us over a barrel. Dominion holds the lease for the 2,000 MW; nobody else can come in and build it.
So if Northam wants an offshore wind industry with thousands of new jobs, he has to do it Dominion’s way or not at all.
Clearly the SCC would choose not to do it at all. But then, the SCC has never shown any understanding of the climate crisis and the pressing need for Virginia to respond by developing as much wind and solar as possible, as rapidly as possible.
In the long term, we have to build out much more than 2,000 MW of offshore wind. As we do, and as costs decline in response to increasing economies of scale and technological improvements, the price tag of one pilot project will shrink in proportion to the billions of dollars flowing into the offshore wind industry and decarbonizing our electricity supply.
If it’s Dominion’s way or the highway, we have to do it Dominion’s way — for now — and then make sure it gets done.
No doubt the SCC would disagree. Yet to its credit, on Friday the SCC also approved Dominion’s purchase of power from a proposed 80-megawatt solar facility dubbed the “Water Strider” project. Unlike the offshore wind project, the solar project met the commission’s prudency test because it involves a purchase from a private developer and followed a competitive bidding process.
This resulted in a price to customers that the SCC felt is “in line with market rates.”
Though the Water Strider project looks like a clear winner for ratepayers, its approval wasn’t a foregone conclusion either. After a long history of approving one fossil fuel project after another, the SCC has belatedly begun to question Dominion’s projections about its need for more generation, at precisely the time when the new generation happens to be solar and wind.
For now, the SCC believes it must bow to the will of the General Assembly. For these two projects, that’s a good thing, but ratepayers will be in trouble if the SCC declines to assert its oversight authority in other filings under SB 966. Dominion wants to spend billions of dollars over the coming years on smart meters, software, burying power lines and other grid projects.
Customers still need the SCC to make sure we get our money’s worth.
The views of our opinion contributors are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of the Virginia Mercury.